Best Italian Restaurants in Rochester

This beloved Rochester gem draws locals and visitors alike with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu offerings that cater to every palate. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 2,000 reviews, diners consistently praise the quality food and friendly service that keeps them coming back. Make reservations ahead of time, especially on weekends, as this popular neighborhood spot tends to fill up quickly with regulars who know a good thing when they taste it.

Mamma G's has earned a devoted following with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for everyone, as evidenced by nearly 2,000 enthusiastic reviews. This popular Rochester spot consistently delivers quality comfort food at reasonable prices, making it a reliable choice as this neighborhood gem fills up quickly with both locals and visitors who've discovered its charm.

The Pasta Villa has earned a devoted following among Rochester diners, with over 1,500 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and satisfying comfort food at reasonable prices. This neighborhood gem clearly knows how to please crowds, delivering consistently good meals that keep locals and visitors coming back for more. With such strong community support, you can't go wrong with any of their popular dishes, though arriving during off-peak hours ensures the best service.

Rocky's has earned a stellar reputation among Rochester locals and visitors alike, with nearly 800 glowing reviews praising this affordable gem that serves up diverse cuisines in a welcoming, no-fuss atmosphere. Travelers consistently rave about the generous portions, friendly service, and authentic flavors that make every meal feel like a neighborhood discovery. Hit up Rocky's during lunch hours for the best selection and fastest service, when the kitchen is firing on all cylinders.

Located in Rochester's vibrant Public Market, Fiorella has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with nearly 4.7 stars from over 600 enthusiastic reviews. This popular spot offers diverse cuisine options in the heart of one of Rochester's most authentic food destinations, where the bustling market atmosphere adds to the dining experience. Visit on market days (typically weekends) when the venue comes alive with local vendors and the freshest ingredients are at their peak.

Rocco has earned a stellar reputation among Rochester diners with its diverse menu offerings and welcoming atmosphere that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. With over 570 enthusiastic reviews averaging 4.5 stars, this Monroe Avenue gem clearly delivers consistent quality and service that exceeds expectations. Make reservations if possible, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly, especially during peak dining hours.

Lucano has earned a devoted following among Rochester diners, boasting an impressive 4.7-star rating from nearly 400 reviews that speaks to consistently excellent food and service across their diverse menu offerings. This upscale establishment draws food lovers who appreciate quality preparations and a welcoming atmosphere that makes every meal feel special. Make reservations ahead of time, especially for weekend dining, as this popular spot fills up quickly with both locals and visitors seeking a memorable culinary experience.