Best Italian Restaurants in Rochester

Fedele's Brook House has earned a stellar reputation among Rochester diners, with over 2,000 Google reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for everyone. The consistently high ratings reflect the restaurant's ability to deliver quality dishes across various cuisines, making it a reliable choice for both locals and visitors seeking a satisfying meal. Given its popularity and excellent track record, consider making a reservation to ensure you can experience what has made this Elmridge Center destination such a beloved dining spot.

Mamma G's has earned a devoted following among Rochester locals and visitors alike, with nearly 2,000 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for everyone. The consistently high ratings reflect the restaurant's commitment to quality comfort food and friendly service that makes diners feel like family. Visit during off-peak hours to avoid the crowds, as this popular neighborhood gem tends to fill up quickly thanks to its stellar reputation.

The Pasta Villa has earned a devoted following among Rochester locals and visitors alike, with over 1,500 enthusiastic reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that goes beyond traditional Italian fare. This family-friendly spot consistently delivers satisfying meals at reasonable prices, making it a reliable choice whether you're craving comfort food classics or exploring different cuisines under one roof. Arrive early during peak dinner hours to snag a table without waiting, as this popular neighborhood gem tends to fill up quickly.

Rocky's has earned a devoted local following with its diverse menu offerings and welcoming neighborhood atmosphere, as evidenced by nearly 800 glowing reviews and an impressive 4.7-star rating. This budget-friendly gem consistently delivers satisfying comfort food that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more. Arrive early during peak meal times since this popular spot can get busy, and don't hesitate to ask your server about the daily specials that regulars rave about.

Located in Rochester's bustling Public Market, Fiorella has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, boasting an impressive 4.7-star rating from over 600 reviews. This diverse eatery offers something for everyone with its varied menu, creating a welcoming atmosphere that keeps diners coming back for more. Visit during market hours to experience the vibrant energy of the surrounding vendors and enjoy the freshest ingredients at reasonable prices.

Rocco has earned a devoted following among Rochester locals and visitors alike, with an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 570 reviews testament to its consistently satisfying diverse menu options. This welcoming neighborhood spot strikes the perfect balance between quality and value, offering generous portions that keep diners coming back for more. With such strong reviews, you can't go wrong with whatever catches your eye on the menu, but arrive early during peak dinner hours to avoid a wait at this popular local favorite.

This highly-rated gem on East Avenue has earned a stellar 4.7-star rating from nearly 400 diners who rave about its diverse culinary offerings and welcoming atmosphere. With its varied menu spanning multiple cuisines, Lucano delivers consistently excellent food that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. Reserve ahead if possible, as this popular spot's impressive reputation and quality at the $$$ price point means tables fill up quickly, especially on weekends.